In a jaw-dropping study, researchers say that a recent mass extinction event in South America never took place! For 40 years, there has been a long-standing belief about a large-scale plant extinction event in a tropical cloud forest in Ecuador. Now, however, an international team of botanists is questioning if it actually happened like history records it did.
The study, published in Nature Plants and led by Dawson M. White of Harvard University, challenges the concept of “Centinelan extinction” — the idea that deforestation can cause the immediate extinction of plant species known only from a single location.
The story begins in the 1980s when botanists Calaway Dodson and Alwyn Gentry reported that the Centinela ridge in western Ecuador harbored around 90 plant species found nowhere else on Earth. They also claimed that these unique plants had likely gone extinct due to widespread deforestation in the area. This dramatic scenario, dubbed “Centinelan extinction,” became a cautionary tale in conservation biology, highlighting the potential for rapid biodiversity loss in tropical regions.
The new research tells a very different story
By meticulously combing through herbarium records and databases and conducting extensive fieldwork, White and his colleagues found that 99% of the supposedly extinct plants have actually been discovered elsewhere. Only one species, a tiny orchid called Bifrenaria integrilabia, remains known solely from Centinela.
“It’s a miracle,” says White, a postdoctoral researcher in the Department of Organismic and Evolutionary Biology at Harvard, in a media release. “Many of Centinela’s plants are still on the brink of extinction, but fortunately the reports of their demise were exaggerated. There’s still time to save them and turn this story around.”
This finding doesn’t diminish the threat of deforestation to biodiversity. The study reveals that many of these plants are still rare and endangered, with over 150 species qualifying as globally threatened. What it does show is the importance of continued botanical exploration and the resilience of some plant species in the face of habitat loss.
“Understanding which plants are growing in a given Andean cloud forest is a monumental task because you will undoubtedly find new species,” White concludes. “What our investigation highlights is that it takes decades of work from taxonomic experts to describe new species in such forests. And only once we have names for these species that are then noted in our scientific networks can we begin to understand where else these plants grow and their risk of extinction.”
The researchers also made surprising discoveries during their fieldwork. Despite reports of complete deforestation, they found numerous small remnants of the original forest and thousands of mature trees left standing in pastures and ravines. These patches, while fragmented, continue to harbor many of the rare plant species once thought extinct.
Perhaps most excitingly, the team discovered at least eight new plant species during their recent surveys. This highlights that even well-studied tropical areas can still yield botanical surprises and emphasizes the need for ongoing research in these biodiversity hotspots.
“One of our most astonishing discoveries is a totally new species of canopy tree in the Cotton family,” says study co-author Andrea Fernández of Northwestern University and the Chicago Botanic Garden. “It’s one of the tallest trees we have encountered, but it’s extremely rare; there could be only 15 individuals alive in Centinela. It’s now being actively targeted by local loggers, so we are rushing to describe this new tree species and get its seeds growing in botanic gardens.”
The Centinela case serves as a powerful reminder of the complexities involved in understanding and conserving biodiversity. It underscores the value of persistent scientific investigations and the danger of jumping to conclusions based on limited data. While the immediate extinction threat may have been overstated, the study reinforces the urgent need for conservation efforts in tropical cloud forests, which remain severely threatened by human activities.
This research also highlights the critical role of herbaria — collections of preserved plant specimens — in biodiversity research. By allowing scientists to track plant distributions over time and space, these “libraries of life” provide invaluable data for understanding and protecting Earth’s plant diversity.
Source: https://studyfinds.org/mass-extinction-never-happened/