Is Body Positivity Doing More Harm Than Good?

‘You don’t have to love your body to be kind to it.’ – Alissa Rumsey

Obese woman looking in the mirror (© AntonioDiaz – stock.adobe.com)

Body positivity is a major topic of conversation these days. From social media to commercials on TV, there has been a growing effort to push a more inclusive image of the human body. While the concept of accepting our individual flaws is a generally positive idea, when does it go too far and start endangering your health? From a medical standpoint, the line should be drawn at embracing obesity — because the condition can lead to life-long health problems if left untreated.

Body positivity is about how our perception of body image (our own and others) shapes our concept of self, mental health, well-being, and relationships. It refers to how you feel about your own appearance, and how you feel about your height, weight, and shape.

Moreover, the term body positivity describes a mindset that the shape or size of someone’s body does not determine their worthiness of love. It challenges the roles of cultural, social, and media influences in the development of our relationship with our body, ourselves, and how we perceive others. Body positivity can also refer to cultivating confidence and self-love, and appreciating your body for all that it can do, despite its flaws. It’s about inclusivity and acceptance of all physical traits.

If the goal of body positivity is to encourage the media to present images of “real” people, rather than idealized images, the movement is succeeding. It’s my unscientific observation that more television ads and programming, as well as print media, feature more overweight models and actors.

(© Maridav – stock.adobe.com)

When does body positivity cross a line into harmful self-indulgence?
Weight is just one aspect of body positivity, but let’s use it to examine the movement.

For children and adolescents between two and 19 years-old, almost 20 percent are obese – that’s about 15 million kids. The older the child, the higher obesity rates rise.

It’s 12.7 percent among kids two to five, and 22.2 percent and children 12 to 19. About 26 percent of Hispanic children are obese, as are 25 percent of Black children in this age group.

We are seeing diseases in these young people which previously were seen almost exclusively in adults. This includes cases of high blood pressure, high cholesterol, Type 2 diabetes, gall bladder disease, sleep apnea, and joint problems. There is more obesity in proportion to decreasing education among parents and lower household incomes.

Obesity in children is associated with:

  • Psychological problems, such as anxiety and depression
  • Lesser self-esteem
  • Lesser quality of life
  • Bullying and stigmatization
  • Obesity in adulthood

Obesity in adults is associated with:

  • Increases in all causes of death
  • High blood pressure
  • Higher LDL (‘bad’ cholesterol), lower HDL (‘good’ cholesterol)
  • Type 2 diabetes
  • Coronary heart disease
  • Joint problems
  • Sleep apnea
  • Increases in many types of cancer
  • Lesser quality of life
  • Mental illness
  • Generalized body pain
  • Poor physical conditioning
Exit mobile version